Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Cone of Learning :: Part III :: Too Much Emphasis on the Wrong Things?


For the past couple of days I've been thinking about Edgar Dale's 'Cone of Learning.'

I suggested in a post a couple of days ago that Dale's 'Cone' might have something to tell us about how we do spiritual formation with students.

In my post yesterday, I looked at the top end of the cone - the end that suggests people learn best through actively participating in what is being taught - and suggested that we might see this most noticeably through the short-term mission experiences we provide for our students.

Today I want to focus in on the other end of the 'Cone' - namely, the end that suggests that passive learning methods [ie. reading, listening to someone else, or even looking at pictures] can be some of the least effective learning methods practiced. When any one of these methods are practiced alone the retention rate is incredibly low.

I wonder how many of our ministries fall into these categories?

Hopefully not many! But is that because we've planned intentionally... or did we just happen to get lucky in how the program came together?

Consider what the 'Cone' suggests about discussion... a 70% retention level.

So we add to a reading group [or a students charge to read their Bible daily] a chance to converse with someone/s about it regularly... and what they retain jumps by 60%!

Or we add a discussion element to what Benson Hines refers to in a recent post of his, "the classic 'sing and speak,'" - our weekly large group gathering - an opportunity to:
  • break into small groups to discuss the message,
  • or a chance at the end to ask questions,
  • or the encouragement to seek out the speaker after the service - or later on in the week - to follow-up,
  • or even the opportunity to participate in a small group with a curriculum designed to co-inside with message for the week
... it increases the rate of retention by 50%!

I wonder if there aren't some simple, yet creative ways in which we shape some of our more passive programs such that the potential for impact is significantly increased...

I mean, who doesn't want that for their students... right?

We want our students to be more than just 'hearers of the Word...' We also want them to be 'doers of the Word'!

How have you seen this to be true in your ministry with college students?


Monday, March 1, 2010

Cone of Learning :: Part II :: The Power of Experience


In my post on Saturday I asked the question, "what kind of impact is your ministry having on those who are a part of them?

I suggested that the 'Cone of Learning' put forth by Edgar Dale back in the late 60s might have something to say to us - both about how we should program and assess what we're doing - in relation to how people best learn and retain information.

As much as we are concerned about students "knowing or believing rightly" [orthodoxy], we must be just as concerned about their "living or practicing rightly" [orthopraxy].

How much of our ministry is intentionally focused on connecting right knowing with right living?

I know that we assume that when we talk with students about the ways we think, or what the Bible has to say about how we live, or even the example of life lived out by Jesus; that they will know what conclusions to draw.

Or that when we intentionally take it a step further to talk about life application that because we have spoken the words that now students will adopt 'what they've learned' as a new way of living...

But isn't it when we've gone into 'practice' with them that the most noticeable change often occurs?

In them and in us?

Of all of the ministry opportunities that we provide for students, and that I myself experienced as a college student, it was transformational experiences of a short-term mission trip that God used to shape me the most.

If you think about it, in how many of our ministry opportunities are our students::
  • removed from their comfortable environments?
  • exposed to people not like them?
  • removed from their daily routines?
  • given a completely different agenda?
  • given intentional space to be with God?
  • exposed to people with very obvious need?
  • put in a position to work closely with those in need?
It would seem that the kind of 'faith meets life' experience that we offer students in short-term mission endeavors have the potential to be some of the most formative...

What can we learn from these kinds of powerful experiences that should inform how we do small groups, local and consistent outreach and worship services? I'll give some thoughts on this tomorrow...

Where [in what kinds of ministries] have you seen [or experienced] the greatest levels of change or transformation?

Saturday, February 27, 2010

Cone of Learning


What kind of impact are your ministries having on those who are a part of them?

How much do your students really takeaway from your sermons, small group discussions, experiments and active participation in ministry?

Consider the 'Cone of Learning' (pictured to the right) or 'Cone of Experience' that was put forth by Edgar Dale in 1969. While this depiction may not be what Dale had originally conceived (click here and here to read about this debate), I think this is worth us spending some serious time considering and using to assess whether or not, or to what extent, what we are doing is truly assisting our students to grow spiritually.

I'll probably spend a few days camping out on this...

So stay tuned and speak your opinion!

Friday, February 26, 2010

Waiting to Grow UP :: Part II


So in my last post I talked about the emergence of a new phase of life known as 'emerging adulthood'. At the end of the post I asked:
  • What kind of effects is this new phase of life having on the faith development process?
  • Are the ways we've approached this age group in the past still effective? Efficient?
  • What can we expect from college student in this phase - both as students and student leaders?
  • Is there something we should be doing to slow down, stop, or even reverse this process? Is any kind of change even possible?
Here are some of my thoughts:

What kind of effects is this new phase of life having on the faith development process?
  • As is the case in all phases of life, there is no 'one size fits (or describes) all'
  • A phase of life that is characterized by increased levels of freedoms, without equal or proportionate expressions of responsibility, will undoubtedly impact an 'emerging adults' faith development.
  • As responsibility is delayed in many areas of life, taking ownership of one's faith will likely be one of those areas that is also shelved until later.
  • A growing and maturing faith would likely lead to an 'emerging adult' who was maturing in other areas of his/her life that would cause them to stand out in comparison to their peers.
Are the ways we've approached this age group in the past still effective? Efficient?
  • Some yes, some no
  • Degrees don't earn us anything.
  • Titles may earn us even less...
  • Young people love the idea of community
  • Young people live online
  • Personal relationships cannot be replaced
  • Personal relationships have to be constantly pursued and invested in
What can we expect from college student in this phase - both as students and student leaders?
  • Again, not all students will fit into one categorization.
  • There have always been students who have been more responsible than others, same with student leaders
  • Students like the idea of having a lot of opportunities
  • Students like the idea of being well-connected
  • Students don't like to be tied down
  • Students like to know that their voice is heard and holds power
  • Many students don't like to be challenged or denied
  • Students expect results quickly
Is there something we should be doing to slow down, stop, or even reverse this process? Is any kind of change even possible?
  • I don't know what kind of change is possible in this 'emerging adulthood' phase of life
  • I think leaders and minister will have to change our approach/es to connect
  • I think we need to challenge students whenever possible to step-up, take ownership and be responsible!
These thoughts aren't complete... but that's what I have right now.

What do you think? What have you seen from where you sit?

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Waiting to Grow UP


If you've worked in college ministry for very long I'm sure that you heard the term/s:
  • prolonged adolescence, or
  • delayed adulthood, or
  • "thresholders", or
  • emerging adulthood, or
  • boomerang kids, or even
  • youthhood
in describing a new phase of life that has sprung up between youth and adulthood. If you haven't, here's a good article that USA Today published on it back in 2004.

What this article suggests, as do the many sociologists and psychologists who study this new phase of development, is that today's "young adults" [ages 18-32] are taking longer and longer to assume many of the "adult" responsibilities in life.

With all of the technological advances, adult-themed media and families struggles that have experienced firsthand, it seems that too many kids have grown up too fast.

Upon graduation from high school and "moving on" - be it to college, a job or life outside of their parents home - many struggle to step into new realms of responsibility. They don't however, struggle to step into new realms of freedom!

These 'emerging adults' love all of the opportunities afforded to them outside of the parental home... but don't care as much for the responsibility side of that same coin. Because of this we have seen the birth and rise of the 'helicopter parent' or the more recent upgraded version - 'the Apache helicopter parent' - yes, this one doesn't just hover, it also attacks!

I've been wondering for a while now how this phenomenon shapes our ministry efforts to this age group. Some questions I've been asking myself are:
  • What kind of effects is this new phase of life having on the faith development process?
  • Are the ways we've approached this age group in the past still effective? Efficient?
  • What can we expect from college students in this phase - both as students and student leaders?
  • Is there something we should be doing to slow down, stop, or even reverse this process? Is anything even possible?
I'll give some thoughts on these questions tomorrow.

But what do you think?

What questions are you asking in relation to this 'prolonged adolescence' factor to our ministries?